Cigar devil logo
Free shipping on most orders over $199
Phone Created with Sketch. Order by phone M-F 1.888.883.5596

How are Cigars Rated?

various brand cigars lined up

Cigars are a luxury indulgence and a testament to craftsmanship and artistry. For cigar enthusiasts and connoisseurs, the quality and experience of a cigar can be measured through a rigorous rating system. In this article, we will delve into how cigars are rated on a 100-point scale, exploring the specific criteria used, what it means for a cigar, and the importance of this rating system.

Understanding The 100-Point Scale

Cigar ratings are a systematic and standardized way of evaluating cigars based on specific criteria. These ratings provide valuable information to consumers, manufacturers, and industry professionals about a particular cigar's quality, performance, and overall experience. Let's delve into the key elements and the process of cigar ratings:

A. Criteria

Cigar ratings typically consider several key aspects, including appearance, smoking performance, flavor, and overall impression. Each of these criteria contributes to the final rating of the cigar.

  1. Appearance: The visual appeal of a cigar is assessed, taking into account factors such as the wrapper leaf quality, construction, and overall aesthetic presentation. A visually appealing cigar with flawless construction often receives a higher rating in this category.
  2. Smoking Performance: This category evaluates how well the cigar performs during the smoking experience. Factors such as burn quality, draw (ease of airflow), and ash formation are considered. A well-constructed cigar should burn evenly, produce solid ash, and draw comfortably.
  3. Flavor: The flavor profile of a cigar is a critical aspect of the rating. Evaluators consider factors such as complexity, balance, and distinct flavors. The transitions and development of flavors throughout the smoking experience are also considered. A cigar with a harmonious flavor profile, offering depth and complexity, will likely score higher in this category.
  4. Overall Impression: The overall impression category synthesizes the previous criteria, considering the smoker's overall satisfaction and enjoyment. It considers the synergy between appearance, smoking performance, and flavor. Subjective factors such as uniqueness, character, and emotional response also play a role in this assessment. The overall impression rating reflects the culmination of the cigar's performance and the smoker's experience.

B. Evaluation Process

Cigar ratings are typically conducted by experienced reviewers, experts, or publications specializing in cigar reviews. These individuals have extensive knowledge of cigars, including tobacco varieties, manufacturing processes, and flavor profiles.

Reviewers carefully examine and smoke each cigar to evaluate its performance and characteristics based on the established criteria. They may use a standardized scoring system, such as a 100-point scale, to assign ratings to different aspects of the cigar.

The evaluation process often involves smoking multiple samples of the same cigar to ensure consistency and account for potential variations. Reviews may also consider factors such as the price point, intended audience, and market segment when assessing the value of the cigar.

C. Publication and Availability

Cigar ratings are typically published in various formats, including print publications, online platforms, and industry-specific journals. Prominent cigar magazines and websites often release annual or periodic lists of top-rated cigars, providing consumers with a comprehensive overview of highly recommended options.

These ratings are readily accessible to cigar enthusiasts, allowing them to make informed purchasing decisions and explore new cigars based on expert opinions and evaluations.

Cigar ratings provide a valuable resource for consumers, manufacturers, and industry professionals, offering insights into the quality and experience of cigars. By considering criteria such as appearance, smoking performance, flavor, and overall impression, ratings help enthusiasts navigate the vast selection of cigars available in the market. They guide selecting cigars that align with personal preferences and desired smoking experiences while promoting quality assurance and driving industry innovation.

Importance of Cigar Ratings

Cigar ratings on a 100-point scale comprehensively evaluate cigars based on appearance, smoking performance, flavor, and overall impression. This rating system provides consumers with valuable information to guide their cigar selections while also measuring a brand's quality and craftsmanship. Whether you're a seasoned enthusiast or a novice looking to explore the world of cigars, understanding the rating system can help you discover memorable and enjoyable smoking experiences.

#1: Informed Consumer Decisions

One of the primary benefits of cigar ratings is that they empower consumers to make informed decisions. With the vast array of cigars available, ratings offer a valuable source of guidance and allow smokers to explore new brands and blends. By objectively evaluating cigars on a standardized scale, ratings offer a reference point for consumers to consider when selecting their next smoke. They can rely on the experiences and opinions of experts to choose cigars that align with their preferences and desired smoking experience.

#2: Quality Assurance and Consistency

Cigar ratings contribute to ensuring quality assurance and consistency within the industry. Cigars consistently receiving high ratings demonstrate a commitment to craftsmanship, quality tobacco, and attention to detail. Manufacturers and blenders strive to create cigars that meet or exceed the expectations set by ratings, elevating their products' overall quality. This drive for excellence fosters healthy competition and encourages continuous improvement, benefiting manufacturers and consumers.

#3: Brand Reputation and Prestige

Cigar ratings significantly impact the reputation and prestige of cigar brands. High ratings affirm the quality and consistency of a brand's offerings and elevate its status within the industry. A cigar that consistently receives top ratings gains recognition, trust, and respect among enthusiasts and professionals. Positive ratings can help a brand stand out in a crowded market, attracting new customers and expanding its reach. Manufacturers often proudly display their ratings on packaging, advertising, and promotional materials to bolster their brand image.

#4: Industry Recognition and Influence

Cigar ratings hold considerable influence within the cigar industry. Expert reviewers and publications with established credibility shape consumer perceptions and preferences through ratings. Their evaluations can impact sales, distribution, and demand for specific cigars. Manufacturers eagerly await the publication of ratings to gauge the response to their new releases and adjust production accordingly. As ratings become more widely known, they shape industry trends and influence the direction of cigar production and innovation.

#5: Personal Exploration and Discovery

For enthusiasts and collectors, cigar ratings provide a platform for personal exploration and discovery. By following the ratings and recommendations of trusted reviewers, smokers can venture beyond their comfort zones and experience a diverse range of cigars. Ratings serve as a starting point for exploring new brands, blends, and regions. They encourage enthusiasts to expand their knowledge and appreciation for the intricacies of different cigars, leading to a more fulfilling smoking journey.

Older Post Newer Post